The Prime Minister followed by private investigators hired by a secretive sect. The leader of the Opposition caught in an affair with the deputy chairman of a prominent right-wing lobby group — an affair revealed by a renegade member of his own caucus. A magazine edited by a fundamental Christian peddling salacious rumours about the Prime Minister’s husband’s sexuality. Allegations of corruption. The Prime Minister depicted as a lesbian Darth Vader on the website of the Opposition’s youth wing. The Prime Minister calling her counterpart “corrosive and cancerous”. New Zealand politics have never been so hilarious.
A brief briefing
Since the September 2005 election, in which the ruling centre-left Labour party prevailed with coalition support from other minor centrist parties, New Zealand politics has lurched from scandal to scandal, often involving a solitary miscreant, sometimes involving actual malfeasance, and always selling great wads of newspapers. The tabloid sideshow that our government and its tormenters have become has been too entertaining to keep within the confines of the land of the long white cloud. It deserves an international showing. And so I present to you, my eclectic international readership, a synopsis of a period in New Zealand’s political history that has been described by many as “a new low”.First, you must familiarise yourself with the key players.
Helen Clark, Prime Minister

Please note: Elements of this graphic have been altered by PhotoShop. The rest was done with MS Paint.
Regarded by many as the leader of the country, Clark has developed a reputation as a tough customer who presides over her party with a heavy but decisive hand. Except when it doesn’t suit her. Despite numerous controversies — an illicit signing of a painting not of her creation, speeding to a rugby game in a police convoy, wearing pants at a dinner for the Queen — Clark remains NZ’s preferred Prime Minister by a long-shot and has enjoyed considerable popularity with her constituents. Some of her detractors say she is a lesbian and keeps many lesbian friends, an assertion complicated by the fact she’s married to one Dr. Peter Davis, a non-lesbian.
Don Brash, leader of the Opposition

Please note: Dr. Brash doesn’t really look this cool.
Brash was once regarded as the brilliant former Governor of the Reserve Bank. But then he entered politics and immediately became a dithering, hapless, Bush-loving neophyte with the world’s most futile comb-over. Since his assumption of the National party leadership in 2003, Brash has been unfairly labelled as evil, racist, and honest. Despite numerous cock-ups — admitting association with the reviled Exclusive Brethren, suggesting homosexuals didn’t qualify as ‘mainstream’ New Zealanders, walking a plank for an ill-advised photo-shoot — Brash enjoys the public support of his entire caucus. In private, however, they all want him out.
The Exclusive Brethren, tosspots

Please note: This is, obviously, a childish cheap shot, but seeing as the Exclusive Brethren aren’t allowed to read the internet, they’ll never know.
This normally reclusive and exclusive sect believes the world is a sinful place and the only way to obey God is to keep to themselves. They failed their God miserably, then, in the 2005 election, when they unofficially backed National with a spectacular smear campaign against Labour and the even-left-wing (and therefore more Un-Exclusive-Godly) Greens, featuring pamphlets that told straight-up nasty lies about the parties — and we all know how hurtful colourful printed materials can be. Recently, it was revealed that the EB hired private investigators to uncover dirt on the government. National party leader Don Brash, who at first denied association with the Brethren and later admitted to it, eventually resolved to cut ties to the sect.
The keypoints
- Labour, knowing they’ve got away with it in previous elections, fail to declare about NZ$400,000 ( US$not-really-that-much) spent on their ‘pledge card’ — a piece of plastic advertising their election promises. The party has insisted it’s not election spending and dispute the auditor general’s finding that it contravenes campaign funding regulations. Obstinately, Labour has refused to pay it back, much to the delight of National, who have seized upon the issue to label the government “corrupt” and gained enormous political capital by maniacally demanding Labour “pay it back”.
- Not incidentally, National was also found guilty of overspending on their campaign, to the tune of NZ$10,500 (US$not-even-worth-mentioning), but have since paid it back.
- Labour take exception to the charges of corruption and threaten to dish dirt on National. Government bad boy (i.e. Sports Minister) Trevor Mallard taunts National leader Don Brash in parliamentary question time with schoolboyish plays on the word “affair”.
- Lowly rural MP Brian Connell confronts Brash in a caucus meeting about his affair with multi-millionaire businesswoman Diane Foreman — a detail many political insiders, including most of the press gallery, knew about for months but weren’t petty enough to bring up. News of the affair goes public and Brash, who during the campaign made a big deal of his wife being Singaporean, is made to look stupid. Fresh questions are raised as to his suitability to lead National.
- The National party rallies around Brash and he resolves to keep on keeping on. Later, Brash suspends Connell from caucus.
- A photo published in the lamentable Investigate magazine — a publication that manages to be at once morally conservative and morally deprived — sparks allegations that the Prime Minister’s husband, Peter Davis, is gay. The picture shows Davis being hugged by a friend on election night soon after Labour’s apparent victory was announced. It was broadcast at the time on a current affairs show. Investigate’s Godly editor, Ian Wishart, explains he published the photo in order to find more information about the other man in the photo as part of an “ongoing investigation” to an “incident” involving Davis overseas in a public place. Subsequent discussion revealed other reporters had already looked into the Davis rumours and decided they were a non-story.
- Helen Clark goes on the offensive, angrily denying the gay Davis rumours and linking National to the smut. She also claims she has been followed by private investigators.
- As it turns out, Clark is right — sort of. Private investigators had been snooping around her shit — but not at the behest of the National party. Nope, it was the good ol’ Exlcusive Brethren who were to blame. A PI comes out of the woodwork to say, yes, he was snooping around her shit, despite completely denying it the day before. But he says other PIs were going through National’s shit, too.
- By this stage, the whole debacle looks utterly ridiculous. Which is why it gets reported in the foreign media.
- Somewhere along the line, Brash and Clark call off the dogs, promising not to slump further into degrading personal politics.
- Clark promptly calls Brash “corrosive and cancerous”.
- Brash, determined to re-assert himself as National’s leader and draw attention back to the campaign spending allegations, accuses the police of cocking up their investigation into Labour’s pledge card spending.
For those in New Zealand, it must be a rather depressing and tiresome state of affairs, but with the benefit of distance, I can say it’s been a rollicking good run. I’ve enjoyed every minute of it.